Amazon UK buy buttons on Knock earn us a small commission at no cost to you. Here's how we choose →

Filed under practical

GPS trackers for kids, when they make sense (and when a phone doesn't)

GPS trackers and smartwatches for kids, the honest case. When they make sense for under-10s, when a basic phone wins, and what UK parents use.

Short answer. GPS trackers and kids’ smartwatches make sense for under-8s who can’t yet manage a phone but need to be locatable, particularly for SEN families. From age 8 or so, a basic phone gives you the same locatability plus calls and texts and is usually the better answer. We’ve read the published UK and US tech reviews so you don’t have to. Here’s the short version: don’t pay £130+ for a tracker if a £40 basic phone does the job, but for the cases where it does make sense, the named UK options are below.

The wider compare-the-two piece is at smartwatch vs phone for kids.

When a GPS tracker is the right answer

Two cases, mainly.

The under-8 family. A young child going to and from school, after-school clubs, or grandparents’ house, who isn’t ready to manage a phone (would lose it, can’t reliably use it, would forget to charge it). For this case, a wearable tracker strapped to the wrist or clipped to a bag broadcasts a location to a parent’s phone, and that’s all you need.

The SEN family where a phone isn’t workable. For some children with special educational needs, a phone is genuinely not the right device: too complicated, too easy to break, too tempting. A purpose-built tracker (AngelSense is the most-reviewed in this category) is designed around the use case.

In both cases, the device is doing the locatability job and not pretending to do anything else.

When a basic phone wins

Most other cases, by age 8 or so. A Nokia 235 4G is around £40 on Amazon UK, does calls and texts properly, lasts days on a charge, and is the more natural fit once a child wants to message a parent back or has a longer journey on their own. It also scales: the same phone works at 8, 10 and 13, where a kids’ tracker tends to get retired by 10.

What a basic phone doesn’t easily do is live location. We’re upfront about that in phone for the walk to school. For most UK families, “ring me when you get there” replaces “I’m watching the blue dot on a map” by the time the child is 9 or 10, and that’s not a downgrade, that’s a change of relationship.

What the published UK and US tech reviews say

A short read of the major published coverage (Wired, TechRadar, Tom’s Guide, plus the manufacturer documentation).

Pure GPS trackers.

  • AngelSense. The most-reviewed tracker for SEN families. Subscription required (monthly fee), two-way audio, fast location refresh. US-headquartered; UK availability via direct import and some specialist retailers.
  • Jiobit. Small clip-on tracker, designed for under-8s. Subscription required. Reviewers consistently rate the size and battery life; the criticism is the monthly cost adding up.

Kids’ smartwatches (calls + location).

  • Garmin Bounce. Around £130, two-way voice messaging via a Garmin SIM, no compulsory monthly fee on the basic plan. The Tom’s Guide and TechRadar reviews praise the battery (a few days) and the Garmin GPS pedigree. The criticism is the limited messaging.
  • Xplora X6 Play. Around £150 plus around £5 per month for the Xplora SIM-style plan. The most-published option in UK retail. Two-way calls, SOS button, step counter, small camera. The reviews flag that the daily charge is unavoidable.

The Apple route.

  • Apple Watch with Family Setup. £249+ plus a cellular plan. Works only inside an iPhone household. Overkill for most under-tens, the considered option for tech-led families.

The named UK options, in order

If you’ve decided a wearable is the answer, the order most UK reviews land on is:

  1. Garmin Bounce (around £130, no monthly fee) for the cost-conscious family that wants two-way contact and location, with the Garmin GPS reliability.
  2. Xplora X6 Play (around £150 + £5/month) for the family that wants the fuller kids’-smartwatch experience and is happy with a monthly fee.
  3. AngelSense or Jiobit for the family where a tracker (not a watch, not a phone) is the right answer, particularly for SEN.

We’re not going to declare a single “best” because the right one is a function of which case you’re in.

The honest caveats on cheap Amazon kids’ smartwatches

The £30 to £60 listings on Amazon UK for generic kids’ smartwatches are worth thinking twice about. The pattern across the published reviews and user feedback is consistent.

  • The SIM slot often doesn’t work cleanly on UK networks. They’re built for other markets and the band support varies.
  • The companion app is often poor. Several have shipped with security and data-handling issues that the major tech press has flagged.
  • They tend to last about six months. Battery degradation, hinge failures and screen issues come up repeatedly.

If a watch is the answer, the £130 Garmin or the £150 Xplora is the version the published reviews recommend. The cheap end is a false economy.

What about tracking a basic phone?

Three things UK parents try, in order of how sensible they are.

  1. A separate hardware tracker tucked into the school bag. An Apple AirTag (£35, requires an iPhone in the household), a Tile (£25-£35) or a Samsung SmartTag (£30, Samsung phone). These are bag trackers, not child trackers, and they work by piggybacking on nearby phones. They’re cheap, reliable for “is the bag at school?” use, and reviewers consistently flag them as the simplest add-on if you need a location signal alongside a basic phone.

  2. Network-operator location services. Some UK SIM providers offer a paid family-location feature. Coverage and pricing vary; check before you buy.

  3. Use a smartphone with strict controls instead. The Apple Screen Time setup or the Google Family Link setup gives you live location plus everything else. The trade-off is that you’ve also handed your child a smartphone.

For most UK families, the bag-tracker route is the right combination: a basic phone for calls and texts, a tag in the bag for “where is it”, and the conversation that “ring me when you get there” is the main check-in.

What this means for a UK family

Three rules of thumb.

  • Under 8, and the priority is location. A Garmin Bounce or an AngelSense (for SEN). The basic phone case is weaker here.
  • 8 or older. A basic phone. The Nokia 235 4G review is the £40 first pick; the ranked list covers the seven the published UK retail evidence supports.
  • Need location too, on top of a basic phone. A bag tracker (AirTag, Tile, SmartTag) is the cheap, reliable add-on.

Common questions

Is a GPS tracker better than a basic phone for a young child? Sometimes. For under-8s who can’t manage a phone but need to be locatable, a wearable GPS tracker is the better answer. From around age 8 onward, a basic phone (Nokia 235 4G, around £40 on Amazon UK) gives you the same locatability plus calls and texts.

Can you track a basic phone? Not on the device itself in the way you can a smartphone. You can use the SIM’s location via the network operator (sometimes a billable feature), or set up a separate hardware tracker tucked into the bag. For most UK families, this is overkill; the Knock first-pick basic phones do calls and texts only.

What about the cheaper kids’ smartwatches on Amazon at £30 to £60? Treat them with caution. The Knock view, drawing on the published UK and US tech coverage, is that the budget kids’ smartwatches tend to use poor SIMs, have weak app support, and don’t last much past six months. The Garmin Bounce, around £130, and the Xplora X6 Play, around £150 plus a £5 monthly SIM, are the two named UK options the reviews cover well.

What’s the difference between a smartwatch and a tracker? A smartwatch (Garmin Bounce, Xplora) lets the child message and call you back. A pure GPS tracker (AngelSense, Jiobit) just broadcasts a location. The tracker is cheaper and more reliable; the smartwatch is more useful socially.


Sources: published UK and US tech reviews of children’s GPS trackers and smartwatches (Wired, TechRadar, Tom’s Guide); manufacturer product pages for AngelSense, Jiobit, Xplora and Garmin Bounce; Apple Find My documentation (support.apple.com); Google Family Link location sharing (families.google.com).


Continue reading

Notes from Knock, when there is something worth saying.

Short notes on simple phones, the parent conversation and the school side. Sent when there is a piece worth sending, never on a marketing schedule. Unsubscribe with one click.

knock.
00:00
Knock